Yummy easy to make Starfish Sandwiches for a Beach themed party!

Looking for an easy treat for a beach or mermaid themed party?  These sandwiches shaped like starfish are super easy and delicious!!!  Check out the detailed tutorial:

When I set out to make Aubrey’s Vintage Beach party, I wanted to include some of her favorite foods.  One of her absolute favorites is the Peanut Butter and Honey Sandwich. 

I’m not a peanut butter eater myself (I know, gasp, give yourself a minute of shock because I am pretty much the only person in America who isn’t a peanut butter eater) so I can’t vouch for the yumminess factor, but my children claim it is AMAZING. 

To incorporate peanut butter and honey sandwiches into her vintage beach spread…I decided to make some Starfish SANDwiches. 

Now…peanut and butter sandwiches are not difficult treats to make…but to save time and energy and make sure that the spread was nice and even, I cheated a bit and bought the peanut butter and honey uncrustables. 

These were PERFECT.  Not only were they the perfect size, but because you can freeze them…they stay perfect and can be cut and stored in advance.

Here’s how to make your own starfish sandwiches:

Star Fish Sandwich Recipe:

Materials:

• Peanut Butter, Honey, wheat bread (or uncrustables)
• Star shaped cookie cutter
• gold, glittery piping gel or squeezable frosting

 

Step one:  Make a peanut butter and honey sandwich as you normally would, or take uncrustable out of freezer.

Step two:  Use cookie cutter to cut out star shape and remove excess sandwich

Step three:  Draw accent lines on sandwich with piping gel.

Serve, eat and enjoy…easy peasy right?

 

Beach Themed Starfish Sandwich Tutorial

Print

Easy Beach Themed Food Idea

Prep Time 5 minutes

Total Time 5 minutes

Ingredients

• 2 Tbsp Peanut Butter
• 2 Tbsp Honey
• 2 slices wheat bread
• Star shaped cookie cutter
• gold piping gel

Instructions

1. Make a peanut butter and honey sandwich as you normally would, or take uncrustable out of freezer.
2. Use cookie cutter to cut out star shape and remove excess sandwich
3. Draw accent lines on sandwich with piping gel.
4. I recommend keeping them refrigerated until ready to serve/ start of party.

Notes

Easy Peasy! Enjoy!!

Nutrition Information:

Yield:

2

Serving Size:

1/2 sandwich
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 309Total Fat: 13gSaturated Fat: 3gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 8gCholesterol: 0mgSodium: 271mgCarbohydrates: 45gFiber: 2gSugar: 25gProtein: 7g

The Beach Printable Decorations are available for purchase in my shop:

If you love this recipe…pin this image to your birthday Pinterest Board:

 

Coordinating Beach Party Supplies

Setting up a beach party is simple with the right tools. These fun beach party supplies will help get you going in the right direction:

Beach party Supplies from Oriental Trading

Tropical Party Supplies from Meri Meri

 

Related posts for Starfish Sandwiches:

• Vintage Beach Themed Party
• Palm Tree Tutorial
• Dolphin Themed Party
• Mermaid Party
• Mermaid Party Ideas
• Mermaid Party Games and Activities
• Under the Sea Party Ideas
• Adorable Under the Sea Party
• Fin-tastic Bubble Guppies Party
• Girly Under the Sea Party
• 30+ Moana Cakes, Cookies + Desserts
• 21 Stunning Moana Party Supplies + Ideas
• Simple Hei Hei Cookies

Thank you for reading our Starfish Sandwich Tutorial!