Sweet + Sticky PB&J Party Games

Keep the kids entertained with some peanut butter and jelly themed games!

If you are throwing a PB&J Party, Games are definitely something you want to keep in line with your theme.  Today I’m sharing the PB&J Party Activities and Games from my little Emma’s PB&J Party.  Be sure to check out The PB&J Party Details!

One of the best parts of planning this party was getting creative with the games and activities.  Some themes have games that just totally make sense and sometimes you have to really get creative.  This was definitely the latter.  

It was a trickier theme to come up with games for…but I think we managed to still come up with some goodies.  Today I’m sharing them with ya’ll.

There is something so wonderfully nostalgic and heartwarming about a peanut butter and jelly party. It’s sweet, it’s simple, and it taps into one of the most iconic childhood comfort foods. PB&J is timeless—and turning it into a party theme? Absolutely adorable. Whether you’re hosting a toddler birthday, a picnic-style celebration, or a quirky themed get-together, a PB&J party guarantees smiles, sweetness, and a whole lot of fun.

But what truly brings this theme to life—beyond the cute sandwiches, pastel decorations, and grape-colored treats—are the activities and games. Kids LOVE getting hands-on, silly, and active, and PB&J lends itself to the most charming, creative play. From sandwich-making challenges to jelly relays, from peanut-shaped crafts to grape-toss games, there are endless ways to keep little ones entertained while staying totally on theme.

PB&J party activities don’t have to be complicated, messy, or expensive. In fact, some of the very best ones are incredibly simple—using everyday supplies, affordable craft materials, or toys you already own. You can design adorable stations that encourage creativity, movement, teamwork, and sensory fun. Even the smallest details—like labeling zones as “Peanut Play Area” or “Jelly Jam Station”—make everything feel festive and intentional.

This theme is also perfect for mixed-age groups. Toddlers love sensory play, preschoolers love crafts, and older siblings enjoy silly competition. PB&J activities can be scaled to any age range, making your party easy for parents and exciting for kids.

And the best part? PB&J parties naturally feel warm, cozy, and full of childhood charm. The colors are soft, the characters are cute, and the whole vibe is inviting. Once you pair your decorations and snacks with themed games and activities, your celebration truly becomes one-of-a-kind.

In this guide, we’ll walk through fun PB&J-themed game ideas, activity setups, and creative ways to keep your guests engaged. Let’s spread the fun (pun totally intended!) and make your PB&J party unforgettable!

PB&J Themed Party Games

PB&J-themed party games are seriously some of the cutest, most unique activities you can plan for a kids’ celebration. Because the theme is so playful and whimsical, it lends itself perfectly to interactive, hands-on fun. Kids love games that let them move, create, laugh, and be silly—and PB&J games check all those boxes!

Think “Build-Your-Own Sandwich” races, grape toss competitions, peanut scavenger hunts, coloring stations with jelly-inspired hues, or a sandwich-stacking challenge. You can create zones like “Peanut Play Area,” “Grape Garden,” or “Sandwich Lab” to make everything feel extra themed. Kids will LOVE pretending to be sandwich makers or jumping into peanut-and-jelly-inspired challenges.

These games work indoors or outdoors and can be scaled for toddlers through early elementary ages. They encourage creativity, movement, coordination, and imagination without being too complicated or messy. And when styled with cute PB&J signage and pastel props, your activity stations become part of the décor—making your party feel cohesive and adorable.

Here are some fun peanut butter and jelly inspired party games to play at your birthday:

PB&J Tic Tac Toe

Want some fun Tic Tac Toe?  I printed the PB&J game board on poster board and used the 2″ circles from the party collection as the pieces.  The kiddos loved the game board!

 

Coloring Wall

One of my favorite go to activities for kid’s parties is the coloring wall.  It is so easy and the kids LOVE it.  A fun box of Sidewalk Chalk and a block wall and it’s their own little art gallery.  Plenty of fun for all.

 

Decorate your own slice of PB&J

One of the fun PB&J themed activities we created was a station set up to decorate your own slice of PB&J.  We cut out slices of “bread” from construction paper and little pieces of peanut butter and jelly (brown, pink, and purple streamers cut into small squares).  

The kids had a blast gluing the peanut butter and jelly squares to their bread slices!

 

PB&J Bracelets

Another awesome PB&J themed activity for the kids was making their own PB&J bracelet.  I got pink, purple, brown and white beads and pieces of elastic string (and also baker’s twine which they actually seemed to prefer).

They strung their bracelets with beads and made cute little bracelets to wear.  This was especially a hit with the girls.

Related: Peanut Butter & Jelly Party + PB&J Cake

Balloon Toss

We also had a balloon toss contest.  The kids were each given a pink, purple or brown balloon to toss up in the air and try to keep off the ground.  Once the kids played balloon toss a few times, we had them sit on their balloons and pop them.  

They thought this was great and it helped with cleanup and kept them from fighting over balloons for the rest of the party.

 

PB&J Sticky Toss

Last but not least…we had a peanut butter and jelly sticky toss contest.  Each family was given a loaf of bread, some peanut butter and jelly.  They then competed to see who could get a slice of PB and a slice of J stuck to their dad’s face first.  

Here is my husband with his sticky, sticky face.  He did not win, by the way, and the guys were super competitive about it.  It’s always fun to get the grown-ups involved in the games.

 

We had a blast with out pb&j games!  Hope you enjoy!

Peanut Butter and Jelly Party Supplies

Here is a cute option if you need this theme to be a little bit more “done for you” than DIY…

Conclusion for PBJ Party Activities

PB&J-themed party activities are the heart of this adorable celebration. While the snacks and decorations set the mood, it’s the games that bring your party to life and keep little guests smiling from start to finish. PB&J activities offer the perfect blend of creativity, movement, silliness, and sweetness—just like childhood itself.

What makes PB&J activities so special is how easy they are to personalize. Whether your child loves crafts, sensory play, competitions, or pretend food, there’s a PB&J-inspired game that fits their personality. Build-your-own-sandwich stations encourage creativity. Grape toss or peanut relay challenges help burn off energy. Coloring pages or playdough “PB&J bakery” setups provide quiet fun for younger ones. Every activity becomes a chance for imagination and joyful play.

These games also adapt beautifully to your party setup—indoors, outdoors, at home, or at the park. And because the theme is so soft and whimsical, the overall vibe remains warm and inviting. Even minimal décor turns into something magical when paired with themed activity zones and cute signage.

One of the best things about PB&J party activities is that they require very little preparation. Most can be put together using simple household items—paper cutouts, plastic balls, craft supplies, play food, or basic picnic props. This makes the theme wonderfully accessible and budget-friendly for any family.

Themed party ware ties it all together. Plates, cups, trays, and napkins in PB&J-inspired colors help your food table and activity stations feel cohesive. Kids love the bright pops of color, and adults appreciate how much thought went into the design without requiring a huge budget or hours of prep.

As your party winds down and guests head home—maybe with a peanut- or grape-themed favor bag—the memories of laughter, creativity, and silly PB&J fun will stick with them. That’s the real beauty of this theme: it’s simple, sweet, and rooted in childhood joy.

I hope these ideas inspire you to create the cutest PB&J party ever—full of delicious treats, adorable decorations, fun activities, and tons of heart. With a little creativity and a few themed touches, your celebration will feel magical from the first sandwich to the final goodbye!

If you love these peanut butter and jelly party games, please pin this image to your birthday Pinterest board:

Want to throw a PB&J Party?

The Printable PB&J Party Collection is available for purchase in my shop:

Related Posts for Peanut Butter and Jelly Games:

• Peanut Butter & Jelly Party + PB&J Cake
• Basic Cut Out Sugar Cookie Recipe
• 55 Best Birthday Cake Recipes
• Ice Cream Cakes perfect for Summer
• Easy DIY Chewbacca Cake
• Milk and Cookies Cake Ideas

Thank you for reading our Peanut Butter and Jelly Party Ideas!